• Skip to main content
  • Go to main navigation
  • Go to language selector
SearchFree text

Swedish Match
SWMA Mar 5, 2021
5:29 PM CET
+ 0.1 % 628.40 SEK
The share
  • svenska
Close
  • Swedish Match websites

    • Image Bank
    • Swedish Match Brasil
    • Swedish Match Industries
    • The Solstickan Foundation (SE)
    • The Snus & Match Museum
  • Brand websites

    Smokefree

    • Swedish Match e-commerce service (SE)
    • Swedish Match e-commerce service (CH)
    • General (US)
    • Longhorn (US)
    • Timber Wolf (US)
    • ZYN

    Lights

    • Cricket
    • Nitedals
    • Redheads
  • Other

    • Swedish Match Denmark
  • Our company More Less

    Our company

    • Our company in brief More Less
      • CEO comment
    • Vision and strategy More Less
      • Financial strategy
      • Sustainability strategy
      • Acquisitions and divestments
    • Markets More Less
      • Our markets
      • Smokeless products worldwide
      • Trends
      • Global tobacco market
    • Organization More Less
      • Operating locations
      • Employees
    • Company history More Less
      • Svenska Tobaks AB
      • Svenska Tändsticks AB
      • Swedish Match AB
    • Corporate brand

    CEO comment

  • Our business More Less

    Our business

    • Smokefree More Less
      • Market development
      • Nicotine products and regulations
      • History of snus
      • Snus production
      • Ingredients in snus
      • History of chewing tobacco
    • Cigars More Less
      • Market development
      • History of cigars
    • Lights More Less
      • Market development
    • Value chain
    • Risk management
    • Outlook and risk factors

    Snus production

  • Corporate Governance More Less

    Corporate Governance

    • Annual General Meeting More Less
      • Annual General Meeting More Less
        • AGM 2020
        • AGM 2019
        • AGM 2018
      • Nominating Committee
      • AGM address and minutes
      • Dividend and financial policy
      • Auditors
      • Articles of association
    • Committees More Less
      • Remuneration Committee
      • Audit Committee
      • Disclosure Committee
    • Board of Directors More Less
      • About the Board
      • Activities of the Board of Directors
      • Compensation to Board
    • Management More Less
      • About the management
      • Guidelines for executive remuneration
      • Management compensation More Less
        • Incentive plans
    • Insider shareholding
    • Corporate Governance reports More Less
      • Internal control
    Participants at the AGM

    Annual General Meeting

  • Sustainability More Less

    Sustainability

    • Sustainability at Swedish Match More Less
      • Sustainability organization
      • Stakeholder dialog and materiality analysis
      • Our contribution to the UN SDGs
    • Improve public health
    • Ensure ethical business practices
    • Equal opportunity
    • Reduce greenhouse gases
    • Reduce waste
    • Eliminate child labor
    • Code of Conduct More Less
      • Group Principles on Communication
      • Group Principles on Environmental Management
      • Supplier Code of Conduct
    • Sustainability reporting More Less
      • Sustainability reporting archive
    • Sustainability FAQ
    • Sustainability contacts
  • Investors More Less

    Investors

    • The share More Less
      • Per share data
      • Shares outstanding
      • Share capital development
      • Share holdings More Less
        • Largest shareholders
      • Dividend information
      • Analysts and estimates
      • Indicies
    • Follow our journey
    • Calendar
    • Financial reports More Less
      • Interim reports
      • Annual reports More Less
        • Annual report 2019
        • Annual report 2018
        • Annual report 2017
    • Financial tables More Less
      • Income statement
      • Balance sheet
      • Cash flow analysis
      • By product segment More Less
        • Sales
        • Operating profit
        • Operating margin
      • Key ratios
      • Statement of comprehensive income
    • Presentations More Less
      • Webcasts and audiocasts
    • Debt information More Less
      • Debt sources of financing More Less
        • Debt programs
        • Outstanding bonds
      • Credit rating
      • Financial risks
    • IR contacts
  • Media More Less

    Media

    • Press releases and news
    • Images More Less
      • Swedish Match logotype
    • Videos
    • Pressroom
    • Media contacts
  • Snus and health More Less

    Snus and health

    • Our standpoint
    • The Swedish Experience
    • Research on snus
    • Smoking cessation
    • GOTHIATEK® More Less
      • GOTHIATEK® standard
    • Snus and the Swedish Food Act
    • Nicotine More Less
      • Nicotine labeling of Swedish Match products
      • Snus, nicotine and nicotine addiction
    • Tobacco use More Less
      • Tobacco use in figures
    GOTHIATEK® Quality standard

    Swedish Match quality standard

  • Career More Less

    Career

    • Employee strategy
    • Our culture
    • Work environment
    • Diversity and non-discrimination
    • Competence development
    • Compensation and benefits
    • What we do
    • Meet our employees
    • Vacant positions
    • Student
    • HR contacts
    Image of employees

    Vacant positions

Our websites
Language:
  • English
  • svenska
Media
  • Press releases and news
  • Images
  • Videos
  • Pressroom
  • Media contacts
Swedish Match's logo
News; Nov 19, 2004 CET

Contradictory opinion on snus in EU

It is clear that the EU directive banning the sale of snus is invalid, since the ban lacks any motivation. Nevertheless, it should remain in force until the European Parliament can adopt a new, correctly motivated directive. This is the view expressed by the advocate general of the European Court of Justice in his opinion as to how the Court should rule on the matter.

"Unfortunately, the advocate general has not seen fi t to give us a legal examination. Instead, it seems likely that he had made up his mind from the start based on anything but legal grounds and then tried to couch the decision in legalistic terms. This is a political position, not a legal one," comments Bo Aulin, Swedish Match’s Chief Legal Counsel.

SWEDISH MATCH HAS ALWAYS maintained that the sales ban is in breach of the fundamental principles underlying European Community law, particularly the principles that it should be non-discriminatory and proportional. The ban contained in the directive discriminates against snus in relation to other, similar tobacco products, and neither is there any proportionality in permitting sales of cigarettes and every other type of tobacco product, yet prohibiting snus.

"But the advocate general has chosen the political line. It is difficult otherwise to understand how he can reason as he does in regard to proportionality and discrimination," says Bo Aulin. "What is the logic behind permitting the use of oral tobacco that is chewed, but not snus. Nasal snuff is also permitted, and the main difference between it and our products is that it is drier. So are we supposed to believe it is the amount of water in a product that makes it more dangerous?"

At the same time, notes Bo Aulin, the advocate general's opinion lacks any legal force. So the last word has not yet been said on the subject. It is the Court that makes the final decision, and there is no need whatsoever for it to follow the line taken by the advocate general. For this reason, it is also pointless to speculate about the eventual outcome, he says. But Swedish Match has always cautioned that a judgment would probably be characterized by political considerations rather than legal and fact based arguments.

"OUR VIEW IS THAT THE BAN is doomed in the long term, since it is ridiculous and is actually counter to the public health interests that it purports to serve. Consumers will seek new alternatives to smoking. Not necessarily snus - it could be other smokeless products also. But this will fuel a demand pressure that will force politicians to act instead of clinging to the totally unrealistic "zero vision" for tobacco use. The focus should be on reducing the health risks," says Bo Aulin.

He also wonders how it will be possible to motivate the ban and present a tenable decision-making basis in a revised directive. The reason why such a basis is absent from the present directive is that there are no factual reasons for the ban, he maintains.

"But the real impact on public health cannot be concealed indefinitely," continues Bo Aulin. "Of course, it is human nature to find it difficult to back down after deciding on a certain position. But what right does anyone have to deny Europe's millions of smokers a valid alternative? Those who espouse the prohibition policy are assuming a huge responsibility."

HE IS AT PAINS TO POINT OUT, however, that a negative ruling from the Court would now no longer be a serious setback for Swedish Match.

"We will not stand or fall depending on the Court's decision and have in any case never anticipated a rapid or large-scale European launch. Tobacco consumers are slow to change their consumption habits - besides which, entry into new markets would primarily generate costs in the short term. But we think long-term, and we naturally foresee favorable growth potential in five to ten years time. This is because we have a fantastic story to tell and a strong message about harm reduction to promote. It is not we who have credibility problems as far as this issue is concerned."

The European Court of Justice is expected to reach a judgment on the issue later this year or early in 2005.

Emmett Harrison

Emmett Harrison

Senior Vice President Investor Relations
Email
+46-70-9380173
Download vcard

Related documents

  • Presentations
  • Our company
  • CEO comment
  • Annual General Meeting

Share

Share Facebook Share Twitter Share Linkedin

Share this page by email

Incorrect email
Incorrect email
Home / Media / Press releases and news /

Contact us

  • IR contacts
  • Media contacts
  • Sustainability contacts
  • HR contacts
  • Consumer contact
  • Web contact

Find us

  • Headquarters
  • Sales office
  • Factory
  • Distribution
  • Store
  • Research & Development
  • All addresses
Map

Corporate headquarters

Phone: +46 10 13 93 000

Sveavägen 44
SE-118 85 Stockholm

Corporate headquarters
Swedish Match

Swedish Match AB
SE-118 85 Stockholm

Phone +46 10 13 93 000
Corporate reg no. 556015-0756
contactus@swedishmatch.com

About the website

  • Sitemap
  • Site policy
  • Privacy Notice
  • Information about cookies
  • Legal responsibility

Find information

  • Search
  • FAQ
  • Archive
  • Glossary

Subscription services

  • Subscription service
  • RSS

Follow us

Facebook Twitter Linkedin

We use cookies in order to provide you with the best user experience. By using our website, you agree to the use of cookies. If you want to learn more, click here.

Close